What happened
Three people shared a three-bedroom flat in Islington, with a shared kitchen and bathrooms, from summer 2024 until March 2025. The two tenants who later brought the claim each had their own tenancy with a company landlord. One paid £875 a month and the other £960. The rent included council tax, water and internet, and up to £50 a month each for gas and electricity.
Islington had made the area subject to additional licensing in February 2021, so a flat shared by three people in two or more households needed an HMO licence. It did not have one. Two of the tenants applied to the First-tier Tribunal (FtT) for rent repayment orders after they moved out.
The landlord’s director accepted that a licence should have been in place. The landlord’s case was that it had asked the council for a temporary exemption notice (TEN) on 10 February 2025, and the TEN was granted on 12 March 2025. A TEN can be given while a landlord takes steps to make sure the property no longer needs a licence.
The FtT treated the offence as ending on 12 March, when the TEN was granted. It deducted £50 a month for energy, set the award at 65% and ordered £3,959.44 and £4,140.50. The landlord appealed. The tenants chose not to take part in the appeal.
How the Upper Tribunal decided
When the offence stops. Judge Elizabeth Cooke held that the FtT had made an error. The Housing Act 2004 gives a defence as soon as the landlord has duly notified the council in order to get a TEN, for as long as the council has not yet decided. The same applies to a licence application. The reason, the judge said, is that “once the notification or application is made, the person concerned has done all they can” (§5). On this point “the appeal quite simply succeeds” (§17).
So the offence ended on 9 February 2025, about a month earlier than the FtT had found. Rather than recalculate day by day, the judge took “a broad brush approach rather than precise calculation” (§30). She took one month’s rent, less the £50 for energy, at 65% off each award. The orders became £3,423 and £3,549.
Water, internet and council tax. The landlord also argued that the FtT should have deducted water, internet and council tax from the rent. That ground failed. The landlord had given no figures for water or internet, and no evidence that the cost varied with the tenants’ use. The judge said: “It is hardly surprising that the FTT was not prepared to guess at an appropriate deduction.” (§24) Council tax is not deducted either. It does not vary with the tenants’ use, and the judge put it on a par with other costs of letting for which no deduction is made, following Vadamalayan v Stewart (§25).
The judgment also stresses that the four steps in Acheampong v Roman are guidance. The amount is in the FtT’s discretion and need not be precisely calculated (§24).
What it means for tenants
The claim period ends when the landlord applies for a licence or notifies the council for a TEN, not when the council decides. Ask the council for the date of any application or TEN notification and check it against your claim period.
A landlord who wants rent to be reduced for utilities must give the tribunal real figures. Council tax included in the rent is not deducted.
The Upper Tribunal also noticed an apparent error in the FtT’s starting figures that favoured the landlord. Because the tenants did not take part in the appeal or challenge it, those figures stood (§§28–29). If you are told that a landlord is appealing, it is worth responding.
For how the claim period is worked out, see our RRO guide.
The offence stops when the landlord asks for a licence or TEN, so check the council’s dates.