What happened
Three tenants shared a three-bedroom flat in central Westminster, paying £870 a week with six months’ rent paid in advance. The flat needed an additional HMO licence. An application had been made in 2022 and the first part of the fee paid, but the second part was never paid. Westminster refused the application on 19 September 2023.
The tenants claimed £21,256.88 against the company named as their landlord and against the freeholder behind it. The tribunal was Judge S McKeown, Ms F Macleod MCIEH and Judge S Nihat. On the morning of the hearing the respondents produced, for the first time, a “Rent to Rent” agreement under which the freeholder let the flat to the company. The previous evening they had also paid the outstanding £270 fee.
How the tribunal decided
Who was the landlord? The tenants argued the freeholder was really in charge. The tribunal accepted that the rent-to-rent agreement was genuine and found that the company was the immediate landlord. Under the Supreme Court’s decision in Rakusen v Jepsen, an RRO cannot be made against a superior landlord. The claim against the freeholder failed.
Was there a defence? The 2022 application counted as duly made once the first fee was paid, so it protected the company until 28 days after the refusal, to 17 October 2023. Paying £270 the night before the hearing did not revive it. The company said it had relied on an agent who later left the country and never received the council’s letters. The tribunal found no reasonable excuse: “This was a professional landlord.” (§216)
How much? Because the six months’ rent paid in advance had been paid before the offence began, it could not be recovered (Kowalek; Pearton v Betterton Duplex). Only rent falling due from 20 February 2024 counted, which came to £21,256.88. Utilities were charged separately, so nothing was deducted. Comparing the case with Newell v Abbott, the tribunal set 70% because the landlord was a professional one. The property was generally in good condition. Against the landlord, the tribunal noted flat-rate utility charges without bills and messages from the agent saying the tenants’ data would be passed to the Home Office. These balanced out, with no further adjustment.
The order was £14,879.81, split £4,806.04, £5,182.27 and £4,891.50, plus £341 in fees. The tribunal said it would have ordered the fees even if the claim had failed, because the rent-to-rent agreement was produced so late (§263).
The wider picture
This is a review decision: the tribunal reconsidered its May 2026 decision after the company applied for permission to appeal. The case shows the gap left by Rakusen, which the tribunal noted (§191). The company’s register entry shows a proposal to strike it off, which may make the award harder to collect.
What it means for tenants
Rent paid in advance before the offence started cannot be recovered, so check the dates of every payment against the offence period.
Check Companies House before applying, so that you know who you are claiming against and whether the company can pay.
See our RRO guide on choosing the right respondent.
The landlord is the one named in your tenancy, so check that it can pay before you claim.
Read the decision
Decision on gov.uk: LON/00BK/HMF/2025/0819
Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.