Three’s a crowd: joint tenants can claim alone

What happened

For several years a ground-floor flat in Islington was let as a shared home to three people at a time, always on a single joint tenancy. The three were unrelated and lived as separate households. When someone moved out, the newcomer took over their share of the tenancy with the landlord’s agreement. One tenant acted as lead tenant, collecting everyone’s share and paying the full rent to the landlord. Islington’s additional licensing scheme meant the flat needed an HMO licence. It did not have one.

Three tenants who had lived there at different times between July 2023 and September 2024 applied together for a rent repayment order (RRO), represented by Justice for Tenants. Each claimed only the rent she had personally paid, £22,421.70 between the three of them, and showed how her share had passed through the lead tenant to the landlord. None of the other people who had shared the flat with them over that period joined in.

The landlord, who was not a professional landlord and had not known about the scheme, accepted that he had committed the offence. The First-tier Tribunal (FtT) found it proved beyond reasonable doubt. It found the tenants’ complaints about his conduct either not made out or minor, and decided that 40% of the rent each tenant had paid was the right figure: £3,147.34, £1,884.13 and £3,937.22. All seemed settled.

A point nobody had argued

At the hearing, the FtT raised a question of its own. Over the period of the claim, the joint tenancy had included other tenants who had not applied. Was a claim for rent paid under a joint tenancy a claim that belonged to all the joint tenants together? If so, they all had to be parties, and the one-year time limit might prevent the missing tenants being added. The tenants’ representative was given a week to make written submissions.

In its final decision of 18 February 2026, the FtT decided that the claim did belong to all of them. It relied on the old rule that joint creditors must sue together, on a High Court bankruptcy case, Re Maud (No 2), and on the civil courts’ rule (CPR 19.3) that everyone jointly entitled to a remedy must be a party. It rejected the argument that an RRO is a civil penalty in a class of its own: “There is no third category.” (§11). It saw the rule as a protection for landlords, who may not know how tenants split the rent and might otherwise face several claims adding up to more than the rent they received. Without all the joint tenants, it said, it had no jurisdiction, and the application was refused. The tenants also had to bear their own tribunal fees.

Recognising that the point was important and had never been decided by the Upper Tribunal, the FtT gave the tenants permission to appeal.

What we and others said at the time

The decision worried tenant advisers, and the sharpest analysis came quickly. Nearly Legal, the go-to blog for housing lawyers, published A can of (joint and several) worms within a fortnight. It went straight to the heart of the problem. Under section 44(2) of the Housing and Planning Act 2016, each tenant claims the rent they personally paid, so there is no joint sum to share out; the FtT’s reasoning sat uneasily with that settled reading. The article doubted that landlords needed protecting, since tenants already have to prove what they paid, and warned that insisting on every joint tenant, former tenants included, would make claims by vulnerable tenants close to impossible. It also flagged the knots the approach would tie where some tenants’ rent was paid by benefits.

Earlier this month our own post, Three’s company: why one joint tenant’s claim fell at the first hurdle, reported a Brent case in which the FtT followed Widdenham Road and dismissed a claim brought by one of three joint tenants. While the appeal was pending, we advised joint tenants to bring every joint tenant into the claim as the cautious course.

How the Upper Tribunal decided

Judge Elizabeth Cooke heard the appeal on 29 October 2026 and allowed it on 17 November 2026. She began by noting that, until this case, nobody had doubted that a joint tenant could claim an RRO on her own, provided she recovered no more than she had paid herself (§1).

She accepted that the law usually treats joint tenants as a single tenant, and that a lawyer reading the word “tenant” might at first take it to mean all of them together (§41). But there is no rule that the word must carry that meaning unless the statute says otherwise. Following the Court of Appeal in Lloyd v Sadler, one joint tenant can be treated as “the tenant” where that makes better sense of the statute in its context (§42). The Supreme Court’s decision in Solihull v Hickin, on which the landlord relied, was about succession to a council tenancy while a joint tenant was still alive, and cast no doubt on that approach (§§43–46).

The context pointed one way. RROs exist to punish and deter landlords who break the law, and there is no reason that should be harder because the tenancy happens to be joint (§48). Tenants usually claim after they have left. Former housemates may be impossible to trace, or may not want to take part. Some may still live in the property, and forcing them into a case against their own landlord is another matter: “in some cases it will not be safe” (§48). The very thing that makes HMO tenants vulnerable, that they are unconnected people rather than one household, would otherwise make it harder for them to claim (§49).

The judge also had in mind who uses the FtT. RRO claims are meant to be brought by people without lawyers, and “it is unrealistic to say that the “natural” meaning of “a tenant”, to someone who is not a lawyer, is anything other than “an individual who is a tenant, whether alone or jointly with others”” (§50).

She then dealt with the FtT’s concerns. Landlords are not exposed to unclear punishment: the maximum is the rent, and the time limit is short (§51). In more than twenty years of RROs there was no evidence of any landlord paying out more than he received; tenants claim what they say they paid, usually with bank statements, and landlords can challenge it (§52). Relying on CPR 19.3 was “to put the cart before the horse”, because that rule matters only if the claim is joint in the first place (§53). And a landlord’s better chance of recovering costs from a larger group of tenants was not relevant (§54).

Finally, the judge pointed to the practical problems the FtT’s approach would create (§§56–58). Unwilling former housemates would have to be brought in as respondents. Any award would have to be paid to all the joint tenants together, with one holding it on trust for the rest. It was unclear how a tenant whose rent was covered in full by housing benefit would fit in. And where a landlord harassed or unlawfully evicted just one tenant, the others would somehow have to join that tenant’s claim.

The conclusion was clear. A claim can be made by “any tenant whether holding under a joint tenancy or an individual tenancy agreement”, and it is “a claim for the rent paid by that tenant” (§59). The FtT had jurisdiction after all, and the UT ordered the landlord to pay the sums the FtT had already worked out at 40%: £3,147.34, £1,884.13 and £3,937.22, almost £9,000 in total, within 28 days (§60).

Where this leaves our earlier post and Nearly Legal

Read side by side, the judgment bears out Nearly Legal’s analysis almost point for point, eight months on. Its holding that each claim is for the rent that individual paid (§59) is the section 44(2) argument. Its finding that there is no real risk of over-recovery (§52) answers the landlord-protection point in the same way. Its concern for tenants who cannot trace, or should not be forced to involve, their former housemates (§48) echoes the warning that the FtT’s approach would shut out the most vulnerable tenants. And it, too, picked up the difficulty over housing benefit (§57). The Nearly Legal article was one of the last pieces Giles Peaker wrote. At the start of the appeal hearing, the Upper Tribunal was told that this had been his last case as a partner at Anthony Gold before he died, and the judge recorded that “he is sadly missed” (§2).

Our advice of 8 November, that every joint tenant should be brought into the claim, is now overtaken: the FtT must follow the Upper Tribunal. As we said at the time, the Brent claim we reported would have failed on its own facts in any event.

Two things have not changed. Each applicant can still recover only the rent she personally paid, not the rent for the whole house, as the Upper Tribunal had already decided in Moreira v Morrison [2023] UKUT 233 (LC) and Marcus v Kwok [2024] UKUT 219 (LC). And the landlord may still ask for permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal.

What it means for tenants

  • You can claim on your own. If you were on a joint tenancy, you can apply for the rent you personally paid, even if your former housemates cannot be found or do not want to take part.
  • Keep proof of what you paid. If you paid your share through a lead tenant, keep your bank transfers to them and, if you can, evidence that the full rent went on to the landlord. The tenants in this case could show exactly how their shares reached the landlord, and that mattered.
  • Housemates are still worth asking. Each person recovers only their own share, so more applicants means more rent back overall, and their evidence supports yours.
  • Do not wait. If you held back from claiming because a former housemate would not join in, it may not be too late, but time limits are strict and run separately for each person. Our RRO guide explains how they work.

On a joint tenancy, your claim is your own: prove what you paid.

Read the decisions

Read the Upper Tribunal judgment on Find Case Law ([2026] UKUT 448 (LC), decided 17 November 2026).

Read the First-tier Tribunal decisions on GOV.UK (LON/00AU/HMF/2025/0753, partial decision 11 February 2026 and final decision 18 February 2026).

Contains information licensed under the Open Justice – Licence v2.0.

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Flat Justice is a not-for-profit Community Interest Company that helps private tenants in England claim Rent Repayment Orders. We write up tribunal decisions so tenants can see how the law works in practice.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *