What happened
Four students shared a house in Southwark on a joint tenancy from September 2024, paying £2,880 a month between them. One of them was given the basement bedroom, which she described as damp and musty, with no soundproofing. She also said the landlord and the landlord’s partner regularly stayed in the house for about a week a month, taking the number of people living there to six when the HMO licence allowed four.
A council enforcement officer later told her that the basement had been found occupied by two people and was “unlicensed”, and suggested she could use that message to support a claim. She applied for a rent repayment order for unlicensed housing.
How the tribunal decided
Both sides represented themselves before Judge Tagliavini, Mr A Fonka FCIEH and Mr W Gibbs. The tribunal was shown an additional licence granted by Southwark for the property for the period 29 December 2020 to 28 December 2025, covering the whole of the tenancy.
That decided the case.
The RRO offences in the Housing Act 2004 are having control of or managing a property that needs a licence but does not have one. Letting more people live in a licensed HMO than the licence allows, or breaching its conditions, are separate offences. In the tribunal’s words, “these offences do not give rise to a claim for a rent repayment order by a tenant. Rather they are breaches for which action can be taken by the Local Authority.” (§10)
The licence schedules were not produced. The tribunal thought any condition was likely to be about not using the basement rooms for sleeping, which would be “a breach of the terms of licence and an offence, but not an offence for which a rent repayment order can be claimed” (§14). It found it “unfortunate” that the tenant had relied on the council’s email when her own evidence showed the property was licensed (§15). The application was dismissed and no fees were refunded.
What it means for tenants
Before applying, check the council’s public register to see whether the property was licensed for the whole of your claim period. If it was, a licensing RRO will fail, however poor the conditions.
If you are unsure, ask the council to confirm in writing when any licence started and ended, and how many people it allows.
Overcrowding, unsuitable rooms and breaches of licence conditions should still be reported to the council’s private housing team. The council can take enforcement action, including civil penalties.
An RRO may still be possible on other grounds, such as illegal eviction or harassment, or failure to comply with an improvement notice. Each needs its own evidence.
Our RRO guide sets out which offences can found an RRO.
Check the licence register first: a licensed HMO, even an overcrowded one, will not found a licensing RRO.
Read the decision
Decision on gov.uk: LON/00AY/HMF/2026/0006
Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.