Three tenants sharing a four-bedroom flat in Islington paid £23,145.44 in rent over a year for a property that needed an HMO licence and never had one. When they brought a claim, with Justice for Tenants representing them, the landlord’s family blamed the letting agents and said they had thought the flat was let to a family. The tribunal was not persuaded. It ordered the landlord to repay £13,887.27, 60% of the rent, plus the £341.00 the tenants had paid in tribunal fees.
What happened
The property was a four-bedroom, two-storey flat in a terraced house in Islington, with a shared kitchen and bathrooms (§14). It was let on a 12-month tenancy from 12th November 2023 at £2800.00 pcm (§16).
Islington’s additional licensing scheme, which covered the whole borough, ran from 1st February 2021 to 1st February 2026. It required HMOs with three or more people from different households, not already covered by mandatory licensing, to be licensed (§21–§22). The council confirmed by email that the property had no licence and that no application had been made (§27).
Three tenants applied for an RRO for the period from 12 November 2023 to 9 November 2024, when at least three people from separate households lived there (§24–§25). They were represented by Justice for Tenants. Judge H Carr and Mr Stephen Mason heard the case on 28th August 2026.
The landlord denied any offence. His family said that the property had been managed by letting agents, that the agents dealt with the council on licensing, and that an email from the agents in July 2024 had told him about licensing changes (§28–§32). They also said they thought the flat was let to a family, not as a shared house (§55).
How the tribunal decided
The offence. The tribunal was satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the offence was committed. The landlord admitted the property was not licensed. The July 2024 email was about a selective licensing extension in two other wards, not the additional licence this property needed (§38–§42).
Reasonable excuse. Applying Marigold v Wells and the agent test in Aytan v Moore, the tribunal rejected the defence. It found “there was ample evidence that the agents were not providing competent advice on licencing [sic] requirements.” (§51). A careful reading of the agents’ email “would at the very least have alerted him to the need to check the licencing [sic] position.” (§53). The tribunal did not find the family-letting explanation credible, pointing to evidence that the landlord’s family knew the tenants by name, and to an email about tenants finding their own replacements (§56–§58).
The amount. Following Acheampong v Roman, the tribunal found the maximum was £23,145.44, with no deduction for utilities because the tenants paid their own bills (§67, §69, §86).
A failure to license is one of the less serious RRO offences, but the tribunal saw this as “a moderate example of one of the less serious offences in which a rent repayment order may be made.” (§89). Against the landlord were the long period without a licence, from February 2021, and safety concerns: “The fire precautions in the property appear to have been minimal and placed the occupiers at risk.” (§91–§92). The smallest bedroom was below the HMO minimum size, and there was no evidence that required safety information had been given to the tenants (§92–§93). The tribunal also took into account the conduct of the landlord’s son, who appeared not to have understood the tenants’ right to proper notice of visits (§94).
That conduct pointed to 65%. The tribunal reduced it to 60% because this was the landlord’s only rental property and he had used a professional manager, however poorly (§95). It made no reduction for the landlord’s complaints about the tenants: the deposit adjudication had retained only £50, and the landlord had once written that he was very happy with the tenants (§96–§98). There was no reduction for financial circumstances because he gave no evidence of income or assets (§99).
The result was an RRO of £13,887.27, payable within 28 days, and an order to repay the tenants’ fees of £341.00.
What it means for tenants
Relying on an agent is rarely an excuse. The tribunal expects landlords to check the licensing position themselves, especially when they are warned that rules have changed.
Safety evidence matters. Poor fire precautions, an undersized bedroom and missing safety documents all pushed the award higher. Keep photographs and records of conditions, and report safety problems to the council.
Rent paid through another tenant can still count. The rent here went through one tenant’s bank account, and the tribunal accepted documentary evidence of each applicant’s share (§64–§68).
Our RRO guide explains licensing offences, evidence and how amounts are decided. It is available via this form.
A landlord cannot hand the licensing problem to an agent and walk away from it.
Read the decision
Read the full decision on GOV.UK
Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.