Four people or two? Greenwich claim turns on who lived there

A tenant renting a room in a Greenwich flat believed four unrelated people were living there and that his landlord needed an HMO licence. He relied on an email from the council and a county court order. But the tribunal decided the case on the evidence of who actually lived in the flat, and it preferred the landlord’s account: two tenants, and a third person who stayed only from time to time. His claim for £2,064.20, the rent he had paid himself, was dismissed.

What happened

The tenant rented a room in a two-bedroom top-floor flat in Greenwich from September 2023, at £850 a month including utilities (§2–§3). Most of his rent was paid through the housing costs element of Universal Credit: £9,415.20 of the £10,200.00 paid for September 2023 to September 2024 (§4).

He said the flat was occupied by four unrelated people and needed a mandatory HMO licence. He relied on an email from the council dated 7 November 2024 and on a county court order dated 19 December 2024, and said the landlord did not seek a licence until March 2025 (§6). He accepted that the Universal Credit payments had to be deducted, and revised his claim to the rent he said he had paid himself, a total of £2,064.20 (§7). He also complained of overcrowding, disrepair, damp and harassment (§8).

The landlord, who held a long lease of the flat, said that during the claim period one other tenant occupied the second bedroom and a third person stayed from time to time in the divided living area without paying rent. She said the flat was not a mandatory HMO, which needs five or more people in two or more households (§9–§10). She had also obtained a temporary exemption notice from the council covering 24 June 2024 to 24 October 2024 (§11).

Both parties attended the hearing on 24 August 2026 in person and gave evidence (§6).

How the tribunal decided

The tribunal started with the burden of proof: “The burden of proof falls on the applicant to establish beyond reasonable doubt” that the offence was committed (§13).

It accepted the landlord’s evidence. It found that during the period claimed the flat was occupied by two people, including the tenant, and that a third person stayed only temporarily in the partitioned living area (§15). On that evidence, “The tribunal finds the applicant has failed to prove the flat had been occupied as an HMO” (§14), whether under the standard test or the mandatory licensing test.

Because no licensing requirement was proved, the tribunal did not need to consider any reasonable excuse defence or the amount (§16). It added that, even if it had, the rent included utilities, so it would have had to deduct something for them, usually £50 to £100 a month, before making any further reductions (§17).

The application was dismissed, and no order was made for the landlord to repay the tenant’s application and hearing fees (§18).

What it means for tenants

Occupancy has to be proved, not just stated. The tenant must prove to the criminal standard who lived in the property, for how long, and as their main home. Tenancy agreements, rent records, council tax details and witness statements from the other occupiers all help. That is one reason we encourage as many flatmates as possible to join an application.

A council email or another court’s finding may not be enough on its own. The tribunal decides the facts for itself, on the evidence put before it.

Universal Credit housing costs cannot be recovered. Only rent the tenant paid personally counts. Where rent includes bills, expect a deduction for utilities as well.

Our RRO guide explains how to evidence occupancy and what rent can be claimed. It is available via this form.

Prove who lived there: tenancy agreements, rent records and statements from flatmates make the difference.

Read the decision

Read the full decision on GOV.UK

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *