Bristol landlord ignored the council’s letters, and paid for it

Three tenants renting rooms in a shared house in Bristol had no written tenancy agreements, but they had something more useful: the council’s letters about licensing. One had been forwarded to the landlord by WhatsApp in January 2022, and two more were sent to his home in early 2023. They showed he knew about the city’s HMO licensing scheme long before he finally applied for a licence in January 2025. With Justice for Tenants representing them, the tenants won orders totalling £9,671.45, between 70% and 80% of the rent each had paid, plus £341 in tribunal fees.

What happened

The three tenants each rented a bedroom in a four-bedroom terraced house in Bristol, sharing the kitchen and other common parts. None of them had a written tenancy agreement. The council brought in additional HMO licensing for the area on 6 April 2022, but the landlord did not apply for a licence until 23 January 2025 (§25).

The landlord did not dispute at the hearing that the house needed a licence. His written case was that he had not known about the scheme until the council contacted him in October 2024. The tenants’ evidence showed otherwise: a council letter forwarded to him by WhatsApp in January 2022, and two council letters sent to his home address in early 2023 (§52).

The tenants also described what happened after they declined to sign a joint tenancy at a higher rent. The landlord emailed them several times telling them to leave, although no section 21 notice was ever served, and in June 2025 he moved into a vacant room in the house (§69–§70).

How the tribunal decided

The tribunal was satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the offence ran from 6 April 2022 until the licence application on 23 January 2025 (§40). It rejected the landlord’s explanation that he had not received or read the letters; that explanation, it said, “carries little or no credibility.” (§56). It went further, finding that he had “decided not to apply for an HMO licence but instead to try to take steps to take the Property outside the Council’s additional licensing regime” (§58).

Following the Upper Tribunal’s approach in Acheampong v Roman, the tribunal took the full rent for each tenant, with no deduction for utilities because the rent covered none (§47). It took a starting point of 50% for a licensing offence of this length and, given the long period, the landlord’s knowledge, the old smoke alarms and the missing safety paperwork, fixed the figure at 65% (§65).

The landlord’s conduct then pushed the award up. He had not protected a deposit or given the tenants the How to Rent guide (§67). His emails demanding that the tenants leave, and his move into the house, were taken into account even though no harassment offence had been alleged; the tribunal said “that adds significantly to the seriousness of the offence.” (§73). It also made clear that a tenant with an oral tenancy “is not required or compelled to enter into a fresh tenancy at the landlord’s request.” (§76).

The landlord’s complaints about pets, damage and missing furniture failed for lack of evidence (§86–§91), and his financial hardship argument failed because he did not give a full picture of his finances (§94). A council financial penalty he had received was not a conviction and did not reduce the orders (§96–§97). The one point that counted against the tenants was that one of them had paid less than the agreed rent, leaving arrears of about £750, so her award was set at 70% rather than 80% (§99–§100).

What it means for tenants

First, documents win cases. Letters and messages the tenants had kept, including their own WhatsApp to the landlord, showed he knew about the licensing scheme. Keep copies of anything the council sends to the property.

Second, having no written tenancy agreement does not take away a tenant’s rights. Pressure to sign a new tenancy, or to leave without the proper legal process, may count against a landlord when the tribunal decides the amount.

Third, the tribunal looks at the tenant’s conduct too. Paying the agreed rent in full, and keeping a record of it, protects the size of any award.

Our Flat Justice RRO guide explains how licensing claims work and what evidence to collect.

Keep every letter the council sends to your home: it may prove the landlord knew.

Read the decision

Read the full decision on GOV.UK

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Flat Justice is a not-for-profit Community Interest Company that helps private tenants in England claim Rent Repayment Orders. We write up tribunal decisions so tenants can see how the law works in practice.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *