A tenant in Redbridge had a long list of complaints about his company landlord: repairs that were not done, a proposed large rent increase, building works, gas meter problems and an alleged attempt to get into his home. The tribunal accepted that these added up to a cumulative course of negative conduct. But it could not make a rent repayment order, because almost everything he relied on happened more than 12 months before he applied in September 2025. Both of his applications were dismissed without the tribunal deciding whether any offence had been committed.
What happened
A tenant of a rented home in Redbridge, acting for himself, made two RRO applications against his company landlord. They were dated 26 September 2025 and 29 September 2025. He relied on three offences: failing to hold a selective licence, harassment, and using or threatening violence to secure entry.
The landlord accepted that, after it bought the property, it did not obtain a selective licence. It said a licence was granted on 23 May 2024, and the tenant agreed with that date.
The tenant described a long course of conduct he said amounted to harassment. It included repair complaints that were not dealt with, a proposed large rent increase, building works, gas meter problems, a storeroom dispute, an alleged attempt to enter on 4 July 2024 and a section 21 notice served on 6 June 2024.
After a case management hearing on 2 June 2026, the tribunal decided to deal with jurisdiction first, as a preliminary issue, on the papers. Valuer Chairman Ian B Holdsworth decided it.
How the tribunal decided
Under section 41(2) of the Housing and Planning Act 2016, a tenant can only apply for an RRO if the offence was committed in the 12 months ending with the day the application is made. The tribunal therefore had to be satisfied of that before looking at the merits (§6).
The licensing offence. The tribunal found that “any offence under section 95 Housing Act 2004 ceased no later than 22 May 2024 when the property became licensed.” (§8). The last day to apply for that offence was 22 May 2025. Both applications came more than four months later, so this part of the claim was out of time (§8–§9).
Harassment. The tribunal did not dismiss the tenant’s account of events. It said: “The Tribunal accepts that these matters form a cumulative course of negative conduct.” (§11). But the question was whether any act of harassment happened on or after 26 September 2024 (first application) or 29 September 2024 (second application) (§12).
Almost everything relied on took place between September 2023 and September 2024. Only two later events were identified: a second section 21 notice dated 11 November 2024 and possession proceedings issued in February 2025 (§13). The tribunal said that “the service of a section 21 notice and commencement of possession proceedings are processes authorised by statute and undertaken through lawful legal process.” (§14). It was not satisfied that either was harassment.
Later complaints of anti-social behaviour did not help either, because “those allegations principally concern neighbouring occupiers and are not acts committed by the Respondent” (§15).
Violence for securing entry. The incidents relied on were in July 2024, especially 4 July 2024, more than twelve months before either application. No later act was identified (§17–§19).
With no qualifying offence inside the 12-month window, the statutory requirements were not met and both applications were dismissed (§20–§22).
What it means for tenants
The clock starts when the offence stops. For a licensing offence, the 12 months run from the last day the offence was committed: for example, the day before a licence (or a valid licence application) took effect. They do not run from when the tenant found out. Once a licence is in place, time is running, so check the dates early and apply promptly.
A long history is not enough on its own. Even where the tribunal accepts there was a pattern of poor treatment, at least one qualifying act must fall within the 12 months before the application. Using lawful legal steps, such as serving a section 21 notice or issuing possession proceedings, was not treated as harassment in this case.
The offence must be the landlord’s. Problems caused by neighbours are not offences by the landlord for RRO purposes.
Our RRO guide explains the time limit and how to check licensing dates. It is available via this form.
Check your dates first: the offence must have been committed in the 12 months before you apply.
Read the decision
Read the full decision on GOV.UK
Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.