Blame game again: Landlords blaming agents doesn’t work

What happened

Two tenants rented a ground-floor flat in Haringey from 2020, through a letting and managing agent. The rent started at £1,500 a month and rose to £1,800. Over the tenancy they reported a long list of problems: a shared fuse box that cut the power whenever the upstairs oven came on, no fire doors, a faulty fire alarm sounder, mould, a leak through the kitchen ceiling, slugs coming through a crack in the wall and an ongoing mouse infestation.

The flat was in a selective licensing area designated by Haringey in March 2022, but it was never licensed. The tenants moved out on 25 November 2024 and, represented by Justice for Tenants, applied for a rent repayment order for the final 12 months: £20,700.

At the hearing the landlords admitted the offence and agreed the rent figure, so the only question was how much to order. The tribunal was Mr A Harris LLM FRICS and Mr S Mason FRICS.

How the tribunal decided

The tribunal followed the Upper Tribunal’s four steps in Acheampong v Roman. The landlords had paid the utilities and produced the actual bills, which the tribunal preferred to an estimate. Splitting the building’s bills equally between the two flats gave a deduction of £2,769, leaving £17,931. Council tax is not a utility and was not deducted (§49).

The landlords said they had relied on the managing agents and did not know about licensing until the RRO applications arrived. That did not help them. The agents did not give evidence, and the tribunal found no reasonable excuse (§41). It noted that the landlords “used experienced managing agents who should have been familiar with the licensing regimes” (§43) and took into account the “complete failure of the Respondents to seek a licence at any stage” (§44).

It found the repairs had been dealt with, though “sometimes not as speedily as in an ideal world” (§38), and made no separate adjustment for conduct. It found no wrongdoing by the tenants. Weighing the seriousness of the offence and the complaints of leaks, mould and pests, it set the order at 75%: £13,448.25, or £6,724.13 for each tenant, plus £341 in tribunal fees.

The wider picture

The tribunal mentioned an earlier decision about the upstairs flat in the same building. There, with no evidence of the bills, it deducted £50 a month for utilities. In this case the landlords’ own bills set the figure.

What it means for tenants

Landlords often try to blame their agent. Tribunals rarely accept that as a reasonable excuse, especially where the landlord never applies for a licence at all.

Keep a record of every repair request and the date it was reported. Disrepair such as leaks, mould and pests can push the percentage up, even when the landlord eventually fixes things.

If utilities were included in your rent, expect a deduction. Where the landlord produces real bills, the tribunal is likely to use them.

For how the four steps work, see our RRO guide.

Hiring an agent does not hand over the landlord’s duty to get a licence.

Read the decision

Decision on gov.uk: LON/00AP/HMG/2026/0014

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Flat Justice is a not-for-profit Community Interest Company that helps private tenants in England claim Rent Repayment Orders. We write up tribunal decisions so tenants can see how the law works in practice.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *